PRO
'Complications arose, ensued, were overcome,' Jack says at one point. Not entirely, but Dead Man's Chest is worth weighing anchor for, regardless. -- Peter Howell, Toronto Star
It's like an amusement park excursion where the entry fee is so high you feel compelled to stay until you get a stomachache to get your money's worth. -- Terry Lawson, Detroit Free Press
For the most part, Dead Man's Chest stands on its own and even makes a few halfhearted attempts to say something. -- Robert Denerstein, Denver Rocky Mountain News
The second Pirates of the Caribbean movie is a sweet umbrella drink leaving no hangover, two hours and 20 minutes of escapism that once again makes the movies safe for guilt-free fun. -- Michael Booth, Denver Post
At two hours and 30 minutes, the story has its repetitive and wearisome passages, and the plot emerges only to bog things down, but for most of its length it positively dances with gusto. -- Colin Covert, Minneapolis Star Tribune
CON:
It batters you with novelty and works so hard to top itself that exhaustion sets in long before the second hour is over... Mr. Bloom, as is his custom, leaps about, trying to overcome his incurable blandness, and is upstaged by special effects, musical cues, octopus tentacles and pieces of wood. -- A.O. Scott, New York Times
The new plot has all the appeal of a seaweed sandwich, being dark, salty, and indigestible. -- Anthony Lane, New Yorker
A bustling sequel that outperforms its predecessor as a special-effects extravaganza but one that can't match the feeling of discovery that came with the original. -- Bill Muller, Arizona Republic
This second film is pretty much all thrills, special effects and nonstop action -- but with virtually no cohesive or compelling story line. -- Bill Zwecker, Chicago Sun-Times
Yes, it's brightly colored carnival fun. But this ride, in the end, only goes round and round and round. Which is ultimately more ho-hum than ho-ho-ho. -- Tom Long, Detroit News
In every other way -- as adventure yarn or as satire on that form or merely as an enjoyable entertainment featuring a wonderfully sly and subtle actor -- it is not merely a loser. It is a disaster. -- Richard Schickel, TIME Magazine
This chest is overfilled with exposition and physical comedy, without a doubloon's worth of the scary suspense that made the laughs in the first one such brilliant comic relief. -- Kyle Smith, New York Post
Calling a summer movie 'action-packed' is supposed to be a compliment, but there's nothing so tedious as nonstop excitement. -- Stephanie Zacharek Salon.com
Rum, monotony and the lash. -- Stephen Whitty, Newark Star-Ledger
It's often unclear what's going on, beyond a zillion dollars of splashy effects washing over the screen. -- Bruce Westbrook, Houston Chronicle
When you find out at the end that what you've just seen is merely the overture to yet another sequel, you can't help wondering what more can be extracted from this franchise. Gold, me hearties, more gold! -- Gene Seymour, Newsday
All of it evidently based on another notion, that great length equals great importance. -- Joe Morgenstern, Wall Street Journal
Although there are memorable bits and pieces, the new Pirates of the Caribbean is a movie with no particular interest in coherence, economy or feeling. -- A.D. Scott, New York Times
The Curse of the Black Pearl, this second installment in the promised trilogy (Parts 2 & 3 were shot concurrently) lacks the swash and buckle of the original. And then some. -- Stephen Rea, Philadelphia Enquirer
Sources include: http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/pirates_of_the_caribbean_dead_mans_chest/?critic=creamcrop#mo